+- Forum PipFlow (https://pipflow.com/forum)
+-- Foro: File Sharing (https://pipflow.com/forum/Forum-File-Sharing)
+--- Foro: NinjaTrader 8 Indicators / Indicadores NinjaTrader 8 (https://pipflow.com/forum/Forum-NinjaTrader-8-Indicators-Indicadores-NinjaTrader-8)
+--- Tema: TF Order Flow V 1.5 (/Thread-TF-Order-Flow-V-1-5)
RE: TF Order Flow V 1.5 - waldo - 07-15-2017
That is something we discussed already. But we still have serious doubts, since if you just want to get rid of all the work with trading and technical analysis seems better to just delegate completely to a computer than just make a partial delegation.
That indication is sort like (to give it some name) algorithmic analysis with manual trading. If it is good then why not just go with algorithmic trading and forget the whole drama of making operations yourself? If it isn't good enought to open operations fully unattended then why use it if is not gonna give you good signals for manual?
You get my point? I don't want to say yes or no. I just want to leave it as "open for discussion".
RE: TF Order Flow V 1.5 - mike83 - 07-17-2017
(07-15-2017, 11:42 PM)waldo escribió: That is something we discussed already. But we still have serious doubts, since if you just want to get rid of all the work with trading and technical analysis seems better to just delegate completely to a computer than just make a partial delegation.
That indication is sort like (to give it some name) algorithmic analysis with manual trading. If it is good then why not just go with algorithmic trading and forget the whole drama of making operations yourself? If it isn't good enought to open operations fully unattended then why use it if is not gonna give you good signals for manual?
You get my point? I don't want to say yes or no. I just want to leave it as "open for discussion".
waldo, i agree with you some times too much information will cause attention disorder since a person can't pay attention to computer screen more that 30 mins during day trading.
For this two options:
display all order flow values only for past 1 day or max 5 day.
or write all values to a text file when we move back or forward the chart during replay or real time.
When you have free time please clone this as new indicator with new name and write all those imbalance order flow , poc, vpoc,vwap,volume profile values in to text file for each 30 min session so that previous day analysis can be done offline. Also that file can be taken back up daily and can be used in next day or next week day trading sessions since too much backward calculations also consumes ram memory and slow down computer.
RE: TF Order Flow V 1.5 - mickiy - 07-17-2017
Hola compañeros sabeis si este order flow existe para ninjatrader 7?
Saludos.
RE: TF Order Flow V 1.5 - waldo - 07-17-2017
(07-17-2017, 11:49 AM)mike83 escribió:(07-15-2017, 11:42 PM)waldo escribió: That is something we discussed already. But we still have serious doubts, since if you just want to get rid of all the work with trading and technical analysis seems better to just delegate completely to a computer than just make a partial delegation.
That indication is sort like (to give it some name) algorithmic analysis with manual trading. If it is good then why not just go with algorithmic trading and forget the whole drama of making operations yourself? If it isn't good enought to open operations fully unattended then why use it if is not gonna give you good signals for manual?
You get my point? I don't want to say yes or no. I just want to leave it as "open for discussion".
waldo, i agree with you some times too much information will cause attention disorder since a person can't pay attention to computer screen more that 30 mins during day trading.
For this two options:
display all order flow values only for past 1 day or max 5 day.
or write all values to a text file when we move back or forward the chart during replay or real time.
When you have free time please clone this as new indicator with new name and write all those imbalance order flow , poc, vpoc,vwap,volume profile values in to text file for each 30 min session so that previous day analysis can be done offline. Also that file can be taken back up daily and can be used in next day or next week day trading sessions since too much backward calculations also consumes ram memory and slow down computer.
I am pretty much against forking since we are going to fork for the paid version, but if you want a log to text file I can add it as an option no problem. You just have to be more clear regarding the "volume profile values" (please be as detailed as possible), the rest is clear to me. The minutes would be configurable. As for RAM,etc I think NinjaTrader can be configured when to start the chart.
RE: TF Order Flow V 1.5 - waldo - 07-17-2017
(07-17-2017, 11:54 AM)mickiy escribió: Hola compañeros sabeis si este order flow existe para ninjatrader 7?
Saludos.
Hola mickiy, no, no tenemos una versión para Ninjatrader 7. Pudieramos considerar portar si hay muchos pedidos. Por el momento solo han sido 2 personas pidiendolo. Lo que pasa es que ninjatrader 7 es bastante diferente internamente al 8.
RE: TF Order Flow V 1.5 - Delta - 07-17-2017
(07-15-2017, 09:15 AM)mike83 escribió: Can you please add buy sell arrows similar to www.orderflows.com/deltascalper/
Hi,
actually its delta surge there I think and its completely free to download...
RE: TF Order Flow V 1.5 - geosan - 07-17-2017
(07-17-2017, 01:41 PM)Delta escribió:(07-15-2017, 09:15 AM)mike83 escribió: Can you please add buy sell arrows similar to www.orderflows.com/deltascalper/
Hi,
actually its delta surge there I think and its completely free to download...
It is not Delta Surge, it's called Delta Scalper and costs US$250.
RE: TF Order Flow V 1.5 - mike83 - 07-17-2017
ok waldo, i agree and i didn't ask that to fork or patch that indicator. they have just included buy and sell bars after doing some calculations and thought it will be helpful for beginners.
if you call your indicator in another indicator which simply writes all key values in to text file during market replay for all range dates like 3 months to 6 months etc so that every one can analyze and take buy and sell decisions on their own and also we can delete old tick data from NT database since its occupying more disk space for all instruments.
RE: TF Order Flow V 1.5 - waldo - 07-18-2017
Ok exactly what you want? Dump all the data range to external file that later on you can open and chart? I mean you want to make a graphic with that right?
RE: TF Order Flow V 1.5 - mike83 - 07-22-2017
(07-18-2017, 01:17 AM)waldo escribió: Ok exactly what you want? Dump all the data range to external file that later on you can open and chart? I mean you want to make a graphic with that right?
I thought it would be helpful for offline analysis if all key values like VAH VAL VPOC , volume Delta etc are written in to text file for each candle and the time frame can be daily 1 hr or 30 min 500 ticks bar ( if there is no issue with computations and memory) and data can be deleted from NT database after a month since i know how much it will occupy disk space to store tick data for months. to be clear, if the order flow key values are displayed as like RSI MACD etc in market analyzer window its good. Just a suggestion